FERC last week scheduled a technical conference for Nov. 12 to examine how PJM determines whether solutions to local transmission needs should be part of the regional transmission plan and opened to competitive proposals under Order 1000.
It also will examine how the RTO and its transmission owners identify local transmission needs (ER15-1344, ER15-1387).
The commission ordered the conference Sept. 15 in response to PJM’s filing seeking approval of the cost allocations for 61 baseline upgrades added to its Regional Transmission Expansion Plan (ER15-1344).
The conference also will address issues raised by rehearing requests filed over the TOs’ proposal to change the cost allocation for reliability projects selected in the RTEP solely to address local transmission owner planning criteria (ER15-1387-001).
In March, Dayton Power & Light protested the cost allocation of a $106 million transmission project by Dominion Resources that was included in the 2015 RTEP. The 500-kV Cunningham-Elmont end-of-life project (Project b2582) initially was designated a supplemental proposal, for which Dominion, as the incumbent utility, would bear the full cost.
But after changing its local planning criteria last year, Dominion asked PJM to study the need for the project and received permission to change its designation to baseline, categorizing it as a new line and allowing the company to reduce its costs by more than half. (See DP&L Protests Dominion Project over New Cost Allocation.)
A supplemental project is one that is not required for compliance with state public policy or PJM system reliability, operational performance or economic criteria.
PJM: No Policies for Reclassifying Supplemental Projects
FERC issued PJM a deficiency letter in June seeking more information on the RTEP filing.
In its response, PJM acknowledged that there are no provisions in its Tariff, Operating Agreement or manuals that explain how the RTO re-categorizes a supplemental project to a baseline upgrade that is eligible for regional cost allocation. Nor is there any documentation that describes the process by which a transmission owner updates its local planning criteria, PJM said.
In its September order, FERC said that PJM’s RTEP filing and deficiency letter response raised issues that could not be resolved based on the record before it.
“Although we are establishing a technical conference, we do not find merit in Dayton’s argument for rejecting the cost assignment for project b2582,” the commission said. “The record indicates that Dominion followed the appropriate procedures to update its local planning criteria. Specifically, after Dominion presented its proposal to add end-of-life criteria to its individual transmission planning criteria at a PJM Planning Committee meeting, Dominion adopted the proposed criteria in its FERC Form No. 715.
“Thus, Dominion’s revisions to its individual transmission planning criteria will not be discussed at the technical conference. Instead, the technical conference will focus on PJM’s application of its Order No. 1000-compliant planning procedures, including PJM’s process for opening proposal windows.”
The commission said the conference also will examine concerns regarding how PJM plans for local transmission projects, including PJM’s “process for soliciting, identifying and selecting the more efficient or cost-effective regional transmission solutions for all needs for purposes of cost allocation.”
Inuit Association Seeks Nunavut Interconnection to Manitoba System
The Kivalliq Inuit Association says connecting its remote electric grid in the far northern, and sparsely populated, territory of Nunavut to Manitoba’s hydroelectric power would be a win for the region, despite the estimated $904 million cost.
An engineering study commissioned by the association said that construction of a transmission line from Churchill, Manitoba, up the western Hudson Bay coast would allow Nunavut to replace costly diesel generation with Manitoba hydroelectric power. The project would save $40 million a year and pay for itself over the course of its 40-year lifespan.
“Ever since I’ve been elected I’ve been pushing for this,” said Joe Savikataaq, Arviat-South member of the Legislative Assembly of Nunavut. “Our power plants are aging and the amount of diesel our communities can hold has to be expended.”
ComEd Project Aims to Boost Use of Demand Response
A pilot project in Chicago aims to demonstrate that demand response can be a year-round resource able to compete in PJM’s capacity market.
The Combined Capacity Asset Performance Project will combine renewable energy like wind and solar with the DR capability of several Chicago buildings. It is being led by PJM, the Environmental Defense Fund, the Accelerate Group and the Citizens Utility Board.
Under previous market rules, suppliers of DR could choose to participate only in the summer months. New PJM rules require that resources be able to respond whenever there is a critical need.
Suburu Blames High Power Prices for Advantage Loss
Automaker Subaru says that the state’s increasing power prices are causing its Lafayette assembly plant to lose its competitive advantage.
Industrial electricity prices in the state have risen 75% between 2003 and 2015, about twice the national rate, according to U.S. Energy Information Administration data. The state had the fifth lowest industrial electricity prices in the nation in 2003, but today 25 states offer lower pricing.
The Indiana Energy Association blames the rise in the state’s industrial electric rates on federal environmental regulations, which have hit the state’s coal-fired power generators. Industrial leaders are pressuring policymakers to allow for the increased use of on-site cogeneration.
Renewable Tax Credits Sitting Idle in Developers’ Hands
Renewable energy developers are failing to build many projects for which production tax credits have been set aside, according to Midwest Energy News.
A study of Utility Board records shows that 113 proposed wind projects were assigned the production tax credits but were never constructed. The study showed that 37 of those were approved in 2009 but received repeated 12-month extensions. Nineteen other proposed wind projects were on standby because the tax credits had already been assigned.
“There are a few projects that I think are ready to go, and are on the waiting list, and projects ahead of them may never be built,” said Nathaniel Baer, energy program director for the Iowa Environmental Council. Baer called for “a fresh look” at the projects if they haven’t been built years after getting awarded the credits.
Kansas Municipal Utilities to Open Training Center
Kansas Municipal Utilities broke ground last week on a $3.2 million workforce training center in McPherson. The center is due to open in June 2016 and is the only one of its kind in a multistate area.
The project is answering the call from Kansas Municipal Utilities’ 176 members, which have aging workforces. The training center would not serve rural electric cooperatives or investor-owned utilities.
The Public Service Commission is exploring whether to allow net metering. The state is one of five that do not require utilities to buy surplus power produced by customer generators.
At a two-hour hearing last week, supporters of the proposed net-metering rules say they would benefit all utility customers, while utilities expressed concern that the rules would shift costs to non-producing customers. State regulators are also considering whether it has the authority to order member-owned cooperatives to abide by net-metering rules.
Commissioners extended the comment period, and it’s not clear when they will vote on the issue, which they’ve been considering since 2011.
State Energy Plan Calls for Wind Incentives, More Renewables
The state’s new Comprehensive State Energy Plan, released last week during the Midwest Energy Policy Conference in St. Louis, recommends adopting a building code, requiring power companies to offer efficiency programs and boosting the amount of renewable energy utilities have to offer their customers.
Gov. Jay Nixon launched the effort last year. The Division of Energy has spent more than a year meeting stakeholders. What emerged is a plan calling for incremental changes that will give the state time to adapt.
The Division of Energy says the plan is unrelated to efforts to comply with the federal Clean Power Plan. The plan does offer dozens of policy recommendations on everything from better energy education to complex changes in utility regulations.
TransCanada, the company seeking to build the Keystone XL Pipeline, is withdrawing its eminent domain claims on the land it planned to use for the pipeline and will instead go to the state’s Public Service Commission for route approval.
The company’s decision came on the eve of the state trial on the eminent domain issue, which was scheduled to start Oct. 19. Even if it had prevailed in state court, TransCanada would have still had to get approval from the PSC to go forward.
“The writing’s kind of on the wall,” said University of Nebraska law professor Anthony Schutz. “The prospect of losing was significant enough that they probably looked at the tea leaves and said, ‘Why don’t we just go forward with that process now?’ ”
Facing a shortfall to pay for retirement benefits, Nebraska Public Power District is asking its biggest wholesale customers for more money. However, 10 local power districts and cities are speaking out against a proposal they say is discriminatory, unfair and even outlandish.
NPPD says it needs $25 million more a year to address a shortfall in its retirement fund. It is asking for a 3.85% increase in the wholesale rate. However, those that sign a new contract will get a discount, so their increase would be just 0.6%.
A handful of cities and power districts are abandoning the public power supplier and shopping for electricity from other producers, which NPPD CEO Pat Pope says he did not anticipate.
Gov. Maggie Hassan will not reappoint Susan Chamberlin, the incumbent consumer advocate on utility issues. Opponents of a Kinder Morgan natural gas pipeline project, who see her as an ally in proceedings before the Public Utilities Commission, are upset by the move as well as delays in finding her replacement.
State officials have known since July that Chamberlin, whose term expires Nov. 5, was not likely to be reappointed. “The dismissal of one of the most powerful advocates for New Hampshire residents, and the significant delay in nominations for a replacement, is a telling lack of concern for all of New Hampshire ratepayers,” said Maryann Harper, a spokesperson for the Pipeline Awareness Network of New Hampshire.
The decision regarding Chamberlin was the result of a review in which the committee received confidential, anonymous feedback from managers, peers and direct reports that were not favorable enough to lead to a reappointment.
Kinder Morgan announced Thursday that it is exploring a modification to the proposed Northeast Energy Direct pipeline route in Merrimack. Barry Duff, project manager, said the company met with officials from two businesses about some newly proposed amendments.
“I am happy that the businesses are being listened to,” said Jody Vaillancourt, Town Council member. However, she maintained the community is at a huge disadvantage because new modifications are being introduced in the final hours.
Kinder Morgan said the original route was amended and moved farther to the east to minimize impact to a nearby school and to avoid conservation land.
Public Service Company of New Mexico and the state’s Attorney General’s Office are challenging an advocacy group’s allegations that PNM manipulated numbers to justify the company’s plans for the coal-fired San Juan Generating Station. PNM proposes to close two of the plant’s four coal-fired units and replace the lost capacity from other sources, including coal-generated power from another unit at the plant.
David Van Winkle, an expert for Santa Fe-based New Energy Economy, last month filed written testimony claiming PNM significantly understated the size of rate increases the utility would seek during the next 20 years if the state’s Public Regulation Commission approves its plan.
PNM’s Patrick O’Connell last week filed a response that said the consultant’s “derogatory and inflammatory accusations about PNM’s alleged manipulation of data to achieve a ‘predetermined’ result are totally false.” Andrea Crane, a consultant from The Columbia Group, a Connecticut-based firm specializing in utility regulation that is contracted with the Attorney General’s Office for cases involving utilities, also filed a rebuttal last week.
Long Island Officials Challenging PSEG Rate Increase
Elected officials are asking for a halt to PSEG Long Island’s rate increase hearings, saying the rate case is flawed because of “constitutional and contractual” concerns.
The request comes a week after the Long Island Power Authority tentatively approved a $325.4 million rate increase. The increase still needs a final vote. In a letter to the state Department of Public Service, 12 Long Island Republican state assemblymen contend that there is “no true oversight” over PSEG and that the LIPA board lacks “objectivity and expertise.”
PSEG, which originally sought a $387 million increase, said it followed the rate increase request process dictated by the 2013 LIPA Reform Act.
NCWARN, a solar advocacy group, installed a solar facility atop a Greensboro church and is selling the power directly back to the church, bypassing area utility Duke Energy. The move is intended to create a test case for state regulators.
The organization says it entered into a three-year contract to sell the power directly to the church as a way to spur a ruling on what it sees as Duke’s monopoly on direct sales to customers. Current law requires the owners of a solar facility to either use the power themselves or sell directly back to the area utility.
NCWARN earlier this year built a 5.2-kW solar project on the roof of Faith Community Church and signed a three-year agreement to sell the power back for 5 cents/kWh, about half the rate charged by Duke. NCWARN is asking the state Utilities Commission to rule that the three-year arrangement is legal.
Staff: PUCO Should Reject AEP Profit-Guarantee Plan
Public Utilities Commission staff have recommended that the commission reject American Electric Power’s proposal that would guarantee profits at some of its power plants.
“Staff recommends that the commission deny the [proposal] as it is currently proposed,” said Hisham Choueiki, a senior energy specialist for PUCO. “However, it is possible that the [proposal], if properly conceived, may be in the public interest.”
Last month, staff recommended that the commission reject a similar proposal from FirstEnergy. AEP has said its plan will help to reduce volatility in electricity pricing and preserve jobs at power plants that may otherwise close.
State is Likely to Meet Stricter Ozone Regulations
The state is expected to comply with the Environmental Protection Agency’s recently unveiled tighter limits for ground-level ozone. Officials were still studying the new standards, but the Department of Environmental Quality said the state likely would fall under a three-year period that includes monitoring data from 2014-2016.
Based on monitoring data from 2013 and into 2015, all counties would meet the new standard of 70 parts/billion, said ODEQ spokeswoman Skylar McElhaney.
Bud Ground, environmental and regulatory affairs consultant with the Oklahoma Oil and Gas Association, said the new limits could put Oklahoma City and Tulsa counties closer to non-attainment status and wouldn’t leave much room for variation in years with hot summers, nor would it account for smog coming over the border from Texas.
Goliad County has set aside tax revenue collected in 2014 from Coleto Creek Power because the power company is embroiled in a lawsuit with the county’s tax appraisal district. The company is challenging the plant’s tax valuation. It was assessed at $353.7 million in 2014 and $403.9 million this year.
Coleto Creek Power claims that the 35-year-old coal-fired plant “has faced dramatic adverse developments” due in part to a newfound abundance of natural gas at low prices. The 632-MW plant also has to contend with stricter emissions requirements and is spending more to transport coal from Wyoming to Texas because a railroad agreement has expired.
Legislation that became effective Sept. 1 requires counties to repay tax revenue back with 9.5% interest, according to the county judge. The next court date is in May.
Hearing Requests Withdrawn for North Texas Gas Plant
Van Alstyne residents have withdrawn their requests with the Commission of Environmental Quality for a formal hearing of a proposed Navasota Energy power plant.
In September, some residents named themselves as affected parties of Navasota Energy’s plans to build just outside the town’s city limits. That would have required Navasota officials to secure an air-quality permit from TCEQ.
A TCEQ spokesperson said that because the affected parties had withdrawn their requests, the commission now anticipates the matter will come back to the commission as uncontested.
More Wind Farms Likely as Part of ‘Energy Revolution’
The wind industry held a two-day conference to promote renewable energy, which attracted several dozen protesters who warned that large-scale mountaintop wind turbines are a poor match for the state.
Gabrielle Stebbins, executive director of Renewable Energy Vermont, the trade group that hosted the two-day conference, said the state’s “energy revolution” is picking up speed, investment and credibility. That momentum will very likely include the ridge-top development of more large-scale wind projects, she said.
The group outside waved signs reading “ridgelines are not renewable,” “stop destroying Vermont,” “no wind turbines” and “save the ridge.”
Republican lawmakers in the state are trying to end a 1983 ban on new nuclear construction. Bills sponsored by Sen. Frank Lasee of De Pere and Rep. Kevin Petersen of Waupaca would waive the Public Service Commission’s requirement that a waste repository be in place in order to approve new nuclear generation.
Similar bills were introduced in 2005 and 2009 but did not advance. With the 2013 closure of Dominion’s Kewaunee nuclear station, the only operating nuclear generating station in the state is NextEra’s Point Beach facility. Dairyland Electric Cooperative’s La Crosse Boiling Water Reactor in Genoa was shut down in 1987 and is in the midst of decommissioning.
Former Louisiana Sen. Mary Landrieu, now a lobbyist, has signed her first client: FutureGen Alliance, the company behind a currently failed clean-coal project.
FutureGen Alliance is a coalition formed to research and develop a coal-fired power plant that would capture carbon dioxide and entomb it underground. Its Illinois project, FutureGen 2.0, received millions of dollars in government stimulus support but never got off the ground after Illinois lawmakers declined to finance the additional $1.7 billion it said it needed. The Department of Energy has since withdrawn its support.
While environmental groups applauded its death, Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin was sorry to see it go. “This is a huge disappointment for both Central Illinois and supporters of clean-coal technology,” he said at the time.
Obama Appoints EPA Strategist to Run Climate Change Campaign
Thomas Reynolds, a top Environmental Protection Agency communications strategist, has been named to a new White House position and will run the Obama administration’s climate change agenda.
Reynolds is seen as an aggressive communications strategist and is the architect of EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy’s nationwide tour to promote the agency’s new climate rules. He has also directed the energetic social media campaign around the Clean Power Plan.
Before signing on with EPA, Reynolds was a regional media director for Obama’s 2012 re-election campaign.
The U.S. Energy Information Administration said that in July, for the second time ever, more power was generated by natural gas-fired plants than by coal-fired plants in the U.S. The administration said that natural gas-fired plants generated 35% of U.S. power in July, compared to 34.9% from coal.
Compared to the same period a year ago, coal fell from 150 billion kWh to 139 billion kWh. Natural gas generation increased from 114 billion kWh to 140 billion kWh. The report said natural gas generation has been increasing its share because of the abundance of low-cost shale gas, in addition to more stringent federal emission regulations affecting coal-fired plants.
The first time natural gas edged out coal-fired generation was in April.
Fed Court Rules Obama’s Waterway Protection Bid Can’t be Enforced
A U.S. Court of Appeals in Ohio ruled Friday that the Obama administration’s regulation to protect small waterways from pollution cannot be enforced throughout the country. A 2-1 majority decided the “Waters of the United States” rule is likely illegal and stayed the rule so it can be reviewed.
“We conclude that petitioners have demonstrated a substantial possibility of success on the merits of their claims,” the judges wrote in their decision, explaining that the Environmental Protection Agency’s guidelines run counter to an established Supreme Court ruling. The appeals court said a stay would be appropriate and provide an opportunity to review the jurisdictional issues.
“A stay allows for a more deliberate determination whether this exercise of executive power, enabled by Congress and explicated by the Supreme Court, is proper under the dictates of federal law,” the court said. The decision comes after a North Dakota judge in August issued a similar ruling.
FERC last week gave Spectra Energy permission to begin construction on a project to expand the Algonquin Pipeline into the Northeast. The agency approved a construction start on the AIM portion of the project, a 37-mile section that will run under the Hudson River and into Connecticut, along with two compressor stations.
The pipeline, which will eventually connect Connecticut, Rhode Island and Massachusetts, is designed to deliver additional natural gas into a region that experienced winter shortages due to pipeline constraints.
DOE: Solyndra Filed Misleading Reports in Bid for Loan
Solyndra, the failed California thin-film solar company, provided misleading documents when applying for a Department of Energy loan guarantee, according to a department report.
The investigation found that Solyndra “provided the department with statements, assertions and certifications that were inaccurate and misleading, misrepresented known facts and, in some instances, omitted information that was highly relevant to key decisions in the process to award and execute the $535 million loan guarantee.”
The report also noted that department employees who approved the loan didn’t conduct sufficient due diligence. Solyndra shut down in 2011, leaving the federal government on the hook for the unpaid loan.
House Passes Bill to Speed Up Tribal Energy Projects
The House of Representatives approved a bill that would streamline the federal permitting process for energy projects on tribal lands. The White House and many Democrats oppose the bill, which the Office of Management and Budget said would undermine the energy permitting process by removing federal oversight.
The bill, introduced by Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska), cuts back on the permitting procedure for leases signed for energy projects on Native American land. Currently, the Department of the Interior reviews each lease signed by a tribe with an energy company.
“We are doing an indirect thing to allow them to … expand their self-worth and keep their identity,” Young said.
National Grid Finds Nobody in Favor of Liquefaction Plant
A FERC-sponsored comment session on National Grid’s plan to build a $100 million methane liquefaction plant in Rhode Island attracted many commenters, but none who support the project.
The plant, proposed for a site in southern Providence, is before FERC for a permit. The comment session drew about 100 spectators, and 33 spoke out against the project. FERC is also accepting written comments on the project.
Talen Energy last week announced the sale of three Pennsylvania power plants for $1.51 billion to help satisfy regulators’ demands to divest assets in PJM.
The 704-MW combined-cycle Ironwood plant is being sold to a subsidiary of Calgary-based TransCanada for $654 million. The Holtwood and Lake Wallenpaupack hydroelectric projects, with a combined generating capacity of 292 MW, are being sold to a subsidiary of Quebec-based Brookfield Renewable Energy Partners for $860 million.
FERC had ordered the divestiture when it approved the company’s formation from the generation assets of PPL and Riverstone Holdings last year. Talen, which had proposed two divestiture packages, last month offered a third option that included the three plants it is selling in addition to the Charles P. Crane coal-fired plant in Bowleys Quarters, Md. (See Talen Seeks Change in Divestiture Options.)
However, the company didn’t wait for FERC to rule on the new request. “We had very attractive offers for those three assets and we decided to move forward at this time,” spokesman George Lewis said.
“We’re not done yet,” Lewis added, saying Talen is evaluating offers for the 399-MW Crane plant and six former Riverstone generators in New Jersey that were part of the first two divestiture options.
The transactions announced last week are expected to result in net proceeds of approximately $1.16 billion. Talen said it plans to use the proceeds to retire pre-payable and maturing debt, positioning it for acquisitions outside the Mid-Atlantic. Both transactions are expected to close in the first quarter of 2016, pending regulatory approvals.
In a research note, UBS Global Research said the Ironwood sale was in line with expectations at an enterprise multiple (enterprise value divided by earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA)) of 8.
But the hydro purchase price represented an EV/EBITDA of 18, about $200 million more than Wall Street expectations. “After factoring in tax obligation on the sale, we see the transaction as adding +$2/[share] in value assuming debt paydown,” UBS said.
Brookfield said the hydro assets were complementary to its 417-MW Safe Harbor facility 8 miles upstream from Holtwood. Holtwood and Wallenpaupack are licensed through 2030 and 2045, respectively.
“These high-quality assets provide a unique opportunity to leverage our operating platform and hydroelectric expertise in a market facing significant coal retirements and increasing reliance on renewables,” Brookfield CEO Sachin Shah said.
Including the Talen sale, Canadian companies have agreed to purchase $11.7 billion in U.S. utility and power assets this year, Bloomberg reported.
Analysts say U.S. utility assets are more profitable than those in Canada. If Canadian utilities want to grow, “it’s going to be on the acquisition side, and there’s a lot more opportunity in the States,” Rebecca Hazan, a fund manager at Leon Frazer & Associates, told Bloomberg.
WASHINGTON — FERC Commissioner Philip Moeller announced last week he will leave the commission at the end of the month although President Obama has yet to appoint his successor.
Moeller
Moeller, one of two Republicans on the five-member panel, announced in May that he would not be returning when his term expired June 30. He said that he expected to serve until his replacement was confirmed.
Nearly five months later, however, Obama has yet to name a replacement. Moeller’s extended term would end when the current session of Congress adjourns this fall.
Even if Obama were to nominate a replacement immediately, it could be months before the commission returns to full strength. Even non-controversial FERC appointees can get enmeshed in Congressional horse trading. For controversial appointees, the process can be even more tortuous.
The seat of former Chairman Jon Wellinghoff went unfilled for almost eight months after his resignation in November 2013. After Obama’s first nominee, Ron Binz, withdrew under fire from the coal industry, it was another five months before Obama named former FERC enforcement chief Norman Bay in February 2014. It took Bay five months to win confirmation on a party-line vote in July 2014.
FERC’s newest member, former Arkansas regulator Colette Honorable, was confirmed unanimously to replace Democrat John Norris after a four-month gap last year.
When Moeller announced his departure in May, speculation on his successor centered on Patrick McCormick III, chief counsel for Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee Chairman Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska). (See Moeller Leaving FERC.)
McCormick’s appointment could have challenged the traditional comity at FERC, given Murkowski’s opposition to Bay’s nomination.
But in light of the lengthy delay since his name was circulated, McCormick may no longer be in contention. Asked by Politico whether McCormick was under consideration, Murkowski said, “He’s a very happy man at the Senate Energy Committee. I’m sure happy having him there.”
Moeller, who was appointed by President George W. Bush in 2006, said he plans to seek employment in the energy industry.
Before joining the commission, he worked from 1997 through 2000 as an energy policy adviser to U.S. Sen. Slade Gorton (R-Wash.). Before joining Gorton’s staff, he was the staff coordinator for the Washington State Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities and Telecommunications. He also headed the D.C. office of Alliant Energy and worked in the D.C. office of Calpine.
PJM and MISO will make a joint filing with FERC later this year to eliminate the $20 million minimum for interregional market efficiency projects, PJM officials told the Transmission Expansion Advisory Committee last week.
The two RTOs indicated their willingness to do so in response to a complaint by Northern Indiana Public Service Co. (EL13-88). NIPSCO, which filed the complaint in 2013 over its frustrations with MISO and PJM’s interregional planning process, says nothing much has changed since then. (See MISO-PJM Cross-Border Projects Still Languishing, NIPSCO Says.)
In an Aug. 14 filing, PJM and MISO said they would lower or eliminate the $20 million threshold. MISO also said it would inform FERC by the second quarter of 2016 on whether it will eliminate its 345-kV minimum on such projects.
PJM and MISO embarked this year on a search for “quick hit” transmission projects on which they might collaborate to relieve congestion.
In a Sept. 3 filing, PJM said the studies found that about three-quarters of the $400 million in cross-border congestion identified was expected to be relieved by regional transmission projects under the MISO and PJM tariffs and that congestion on lower voltage facilities could be eliminated by upgrades costing less than $5 million.
“Reduction or elimination of the $20 million threshold in the [joint operating agreement] and the [345-kV] voltage threshold in MISO’s regional process would enable quick-hit projects to qualify as an interregional project,” PJM said.
PJM officials said they and MISO officials will make a joint filing to remove the $20 million threshold from their Joint Operating Agreement. MISO would file alone if it decides to eliminate the 345-kV threshold from its Tariff.
AEP to Build Rockport Line as Supplemental Project
American Electric Power will build a 14-mile double-circuit line between its Rockport substation and MISO’s Duff-Coleman 345-kV line as a supplemental project in the PJM Regional Transmission Expansion Plan. The project, which is intended to solve stability problems at the substation, will piggyback on MISO’s planned Duff-Rockport-Coleman project. (See MISO Staff Recommends 3 Economic Projects.)
Cost sharing for Duff-Rockport-Coleman (Source: MISO)
“We clearly should have gotten involved [in the project planning] much earlier,” said Steve Herling, vice president of planning. “MISO was great,” he added, noting that MISO delayed its process to allow PJM to conduct its own analyses.
“We’ve already had a number of conversations with MISO as to how we can be better synched up in the future,” Herling said. “We’re pretty happy it didn’t fall through the cracks. Next time we want to do it in a more formalized way.” (See related story, FERC Sets Nov. 12 Tech Conference on PJM Tx Planning Rules.)
Most AP South/AEP-DOM Proposals Clear Sensitivity Tests
All but one of 11 proposals that passed the initial benefit-cost ratio to address congestion in the AP South/AEP-DOM area also show positive benefits under 10 different sensitivity analyses, PJM planners told the TEAC.
The sensitivities included fuel prices (+/- $1/MMBtu), load forecasts (+/- 2%), interface ratings (changes in anticipated project impacts by 20%) and combinations of fuel price and load forecast sensitivities.
All but two of the projects cleared the 1.25 B-C ratio under all sensitivities and all but one showed congestion savings for the entire RTO. However, nine of the 11 worsened congestion on AEP-DOM alone (see chart).
Planners will continue their analysis by combining components of multiple projects as well as considering projects involving capacitors and reactive devices.
Planners evaluated six planned market efficiency projects but determined that none of them should be accelerated because the projects are either too large to reschedule or their in-service dates are in the near future. An additional six projects expected to reduce congestion also were ineligible because they are being developed by MISO.
SVCs Recommended to Fix High Voltage in AEP, PSEG
Planners will recommend more than $51 million in upgrades to address high voltages in the AEP and PSEG transmission zones.
The AEP project would involve installation of a 450-MVAR static VAR compensator (SVC) at the Jacksons Ferry 765-kV substation and a 300-MVAR shunt line reactor on the Broadford end of the Broadford-Jacksons Ferry 765-kV line. It is expected to be in service in June 2018 at a cost of $51 million.
Planners also will recommend six shunt reactors on the PSEG system in addition to about 1,500 MVARs of approved reactors and SVCs planned to go in service by 2016. Three devices are required as soon as possible; the other three will be installed in coordination with the Bergen-Linden Corridor 345-kV project. No cost estimate was listed for these projects.
Planners Choose $25.8M AEP Proposal over Cheaper LS Power Option
PJM will recommend AEP’s proposed $25.8 million upgrade rather than a $7.4 million proposal by LS Power to address low voltage and overload problems in the AEP zone.
Paul McGlynn, general manager of system planning, said PJM determined that LS Power’s proposal to build a new Grassy Creek switching station would be insufficient to address expected load growth driven by shale gas production in the area. The AEP project, due in service by June 2020, is expected to prevent violations for at least 15 years, PJM said.
“We believe [the AEP project] is the better, more robust solution,” he said.
LS Power’s Sharon Segner questioned why AEP’s more expensive project was selected, saying PJM’s load growth assumptions are too high. “We want to make sure the right solution is picked, even if at the end of it, AEP takes the idea that we proposed,” she said.
Dominion to Spend $273M+ on End-of-Life Projects
Dominion Virginia Power will spend more than $273 million on nine projects to replace aging transmission lines in accordance with its “end of life” criteria, which sets the lifespans for wooden structures, conductors, connectors and porcelain insulators.
The rebuild of the Cunningham-Dooms 500-kV line is expected to cost more than $100 million, with an in-service date of June 2020. Eight other projects, expected to be completed between 2016 and 2019, will total about $173 million.
Exelon Retiring Perryman Unit in BGE
Exelon has decided to retire, rather than repair, its damaged 51-MW Perryman 2 generator in the BGE zone.
Exelon told FERC in April that the 43-year-old oil-fired unit experienced a “severe mechanical failure” in February that would take nine months to repair (ER15-1611).
Exelon said that a portion of a compressor shroud detached, damaging a number of the compressor’s components. “In addition to the compressor issue, electrical testing revealed that the unit’s generator field and stator windings are in a degraded condition,” Exelon said.
PJM planners are conducting a reliability analysis on the retirement request, which was filed Oct. 2. Exelon requested the retirement be effective Jan. 1.
In May, the D.C. Council unanimously approved $250,000 for the Office of the People’s Counsel to conduct a study on the feasibility of the district replacing Potomac Electric Power Co. with a city-owned utility.
The vote set lobbyists for Pepco — no strangers to the Wilson Building, D.C.’s city hall — into high alert.
Public records show that in June alone, Pepco and Exelon lobbyists Tina Ang and John Ray, of law firm Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, communicated more than 60 times with seven D.C. councilmembers or their aides, including in-person meetings, phone calls and electronic messages.
By the end of the month, the study — included in the city’s fiscal year 2016 budget — was dead, with the council voting 7-6 to reallocate the funds for a study on “emerging alternatives” for energy and energy efficiency.
“Presumably, they didn’t even want a study,” said Councilwoman Mary Cheh, an opponent of Exelon’s bid to acquire Pepco who had pushed for the original study.
The amendment to reallocate the funds was sponsored by Councilmember Anita Bonds. Bonds or her staff communicated on 19 occasions with the utility lobbyists in June. Councilmembers Jack Evans, Brandon Todd, LaRuby May and Vincent Orange — all of whom met personally with the lobbyists — and Yvette Alexander, who sent a staff member to the meetings, also voted for the change.
The vote was but one signal of Pepco’s clout in the district.
Orange, a former regional vice president for PHI, chairs the Council’s Committee Business, Consumer and Regulatory Affairs.
Council Chairman Phil Mendelson has been criticized for voting on Pepco matters because he holds enough stock to be required to financially disclose it.
Attorney General Karl Racine, who helped negotiate the Oct. 6 settlement between Exelon and Mayor Muriel Bowser, and Racine deputy Natalie Ludaway conducted work on Pepco’s behalf while at their former law firms. Beverly Perry, senior adviser to Bowser, retired in 2013 as senior vice president and special adviser to the chairman of PHI.
Charity Returned?
In their bid to win approval of the merger, Pepco officials also have looked to cash in chits with the dozens of community organizations the company supports with charitable contributions. In the district alone, Pepco spends about $1.6 million annually on charitable contributions.
Exelon and Pepco claim that more than 80 D.C.-area organizations support the merger, including 30 businesses and associations and nearly four dozen non-profit organizations. At least half of the non-profit groups listed in support were recipients of contributions from Pepco in 2014 or receive funding from the United Way of the National Capital Area, where Pepco CEO Joseph Rigby is the immediate past chairman. John Huffman, CEO of Pepco Energy Services, serves on the board of the Capital Area Food Bank, one of the charitable groups backing the deal.
Business Community Lines up in Support
Rigby also serves on the senior council of the Greater Washington Board of Trade, as well as the boards of the Federal City Council and the Economic Club of Washington — all of which have endorsed the merger.
James C. Dinegar, president of the Board of Trade, told The Washington Post that rejection of the deal would hurt the region’s economy. “There’s a big concern that we’re hanging out the ‘Closed for Business’ sign in the District of Columbia,” he said.
The powerhouse at Duke Energy’s retired Cliffside Steam Station in Mooresboro, N.C., came down in a cloud of dust last week, the latest demolition Duke has conducted to modernize its generation fleet.
The coal-fired station went into service in 1940, and units 1 through 4 were retired in 2011. Units 5 and 6 are coal-fired units equipped with modern scrubber technology and still operate as part of the James E. Rogers Energy Complex.
Entergy Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer Mark Savoff and Executive Vice President and Chief Nuclear Officer Jeff Forbes announced coordinated retirement dates last week.
Both executives plan to shift to advisory roles on Nov. 1 before retiring in 2016’s first quarter. At that time, Tim Mitchell, Entergy’s senior vice president of nuclear operations, will be named acting chief nuclear officer. In an executive restructure, the chief nuclear officer will directly report to Entergy Chairman and CEO Leo Denault. Mitchell will also be a candidate in Entergy’s search for a permanent chief nuclear officer.
Savoff and Forbes joined Entergy in 2003 and oversaw the transition of Entergy’s transmission system to MISO in 2013.
DTE Energy is teaming up with GE Hitachi to design a new type of boiling water reactor. While others are working on smaller, modular designs, the two companies are working on advancing the first-ever Economic Simplified Boiling Water Reactor (ESBWR).
The ESBWR incorporates passive safety systems, including a reactor that can cool itself for more than seven days without backup power or any human input. DTE has already received licensing from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission for the ESBWR.
The company said it has no current plans to start construction but said it is “keeping the option open, given the long-term environmental and economic advantages of nuclear power.” Dominion Virginia Power has selected the new design for a possible third reactor at its North Anna site in Virginia.
Alliant Energy subsidiary Interstate Power & Light in Iowa is planning to increase its total solar energy capacity by 50%, according to a recent request for proposals.
The company said it is looking to develop solar projects of between 1 and 10 MW. It currently purchases about 22 MW of solar capacity from about 1,650 customers in its service territory.
Alliant said the plan is unrelated to an Environmental Protection Agency air emissions settlement that calls for it to spend $6 million on environmental mitigation projects, which could include solar generation.
Xcel Energy to Accelerate Minnesota Wind, Solar Investments
Xcel Energy says it will reduce its greenhouse gas emissions in Minnesota by increasing wind and solar power investment and replacing two coal-burning generators with a natural gas-fired unit in the mid-2020s.
The plan, submitted to state regulators, would reduce carbon dioxide emissions in the Upper Midwest 60% by 2030 compared with 2005 levels. Until now, Xcel had aimed for a 40% reduction over that period.
Two of the three coal-fired units at Xcel’s Sherco power plant — Xcel’s largest in the region — would be retired in 2023 and 2026 under the plan. The two units, built in the 1970s, would be replaced by a new power plant fueled by natural gas.
PSEG Combined-Cycle Project to Deliver Power by Summer 2018
Construction on PSEG Power’s 540-MW Sewaren 7 combined-cycle project is expected to begin next year at an existing power station site in Woodbridge, N.J.
The $600 million dual-fuel gas-turbine facility is set to deliver power to the PJM market for the summer of 2018.
The project was finalized after clearing the Base Residual Auction in August.
Residents in Onalaska, Wis., are concerned over Dairyland Power Cooperative’s planned replacement of a 65-year-old 161-kV line.
Dairyland, which is based in La Crosse, has been working nearly a decade to replace the 9-mile stretch of line connecting power plants in Alma and Genoa to the grid, and designs are not yet ready, in spite of a late 2016 start date. The cost of the project is calculated between $7 million and $8 million. Other transmission lines in the area have been rebuilt recently or are in the process of replacement.
Residents are worried that the new line, which will carry twice the electricity at the same voltage, will increase exposure to electromagnetic radiation. Dairyland says raising the wires will mitigate exposure.
NuScale Seeking British Partners for Modular Reactor Design
NuScale Power, a U.S. company developing a small modular reactor with the help of a $217 million Department of Energy grant, is looking for a partner to help make the design a reality in the United Kingdom.
The company, mostly owned by Fluor Corp., is distributing a prospectus in the U.K. seeking a partner in what it says is a chance to get a piece of the $612 billion nuclear market by 2035.
NuScale’s design is on track to come up for U.S. certification next year, and the company says it expects to receive U.S. regulatory approval in the early 2020s. It is currently developing a test model in Idaho, using technology that can be customized for scale, allowing deployment in series, with up to 12 small reactors totaling about 600 MW.
Northern Indiana natural gas and electric provider NIPSCO has asked state regulators for an 11.5% hike in residential electric rates. Indiana’s industrial utility customers are protesting the request.
Joseph Hamrock, CEO of NiSource, parent company for NIPSCO and utilities in six other states, said the increases are needed to fund plants, poles and wires that serve as fail-safes even in light of new generating technologies.
South Field Energy to Build 1,100-MW Nat Gas Plant in Ohio
South Field Energy announced plans to build a $1.1 billion, 1,100-MW natural gas-fired power plant in Columbiana County, Ohio.
South Field and other companies are taking advantage of the cheap gas being produced at Utica Shale fields in the state. It is the sixth natural gas plant under construction in Ohio, according to the Akron Beacon Journal.
Construction would start in 2017, and the plant should be operational by 2019. South Field is also building an $899 million gas-fired plant in Carroll County.
Ameren increased its quarterly dividend on common stock, from 41 cents/share of common stock to 42.5 cents, an increase of 3.7%. The common share dividend is payable Dec. 31 to shareholders of record at the close of business on Dec. 9. The company’s board of directors also declared quarterly cash dividends to all classes of Ameren Missouri stock and all classes of Ameren Illinois preferred stock.
A study released last week by the American Public Power Association estimates that PJM’s Capacity Performance rules will increase costs to consumers by $7.3 billion over the 2016-2019 delivery years — a tally in line with PJM’s own estimates.
But while PJM says the increased capacity costs will pay off in improved reliability and reduced energy market prices, APPA says the spending is not justified.
“PJM’s recent changes are an over-reaction to the ‘polar vortex’ and address a problem that was largely already addressed by PJM and market participants through various other measures,” said Joe Nipper, APPA’s senior vice president of regulatory affairs and communications. “As a result, bill-paying consumers will pay a lot more for the same product.”
The report was prepared by James Wilson, who also consults for state consumer advocates in PJM. Wilson said that the transition auctions recently held for the 2016/17 and 2017/18 delivery years resulted in $4 billion in additional costs to upgrade 60% and 70% of “base” capacity to Capacity Performance, respectively.
In addition Wilson estimates that the Base Residual Auction for 2018/19, which cleared at $164.77/MW-day, would have cleared at $124.23/MW-day if not for the requirement that 80% of the resources acquired be CP. That, Wilson said, increased the total BRA cost to $10.9 billion, an increase of $3.3 billion. Wilson’s quantitative findings are in line with PJM’s own calculations.
PJM said the incremental cost of the 2016/17 transition auction was $2.3 billion, slightly below the estimate of $2.5 billion to $3.6 billion PJM and the Independent Market Monitor had predicted in a joint analysis. The increase for 2017/18 was $1.7 billion, PJM said (versus an estimate of $3.1 billion to $4.2 billion).
The RTO said the 2018/19 BRA represented a $3.4 billion increase over the previous year’s auction, an amount that is within the $2 billion to $5 billion range PJM and the Monitor had expected. (See PJM Transition Auction Means Reprieve for Exelon Nukes.)
Different Conclusions
But while Wilson’s math generally agrees with PJM’s, he does not agree with the RTO over what ratepayers are getting for their money.
“Improved generator performance certainly would have resulted in much lower energy costs during the ‘polar vortex’ period of extreme cold in early 2014, when very high forced outage rates caused price spikes in the PJM energy markets,” Wilson wrote. “However, that very extreme period followed 19 winters during which such extreme cold did not occur, capacity was never scarce during winter and winter energy prices remained low in PJM.
“The polar vortex period revealed accumulated fuel and winterization issues at many plants. Apparently, many of these issues were resolved by the winter of 2015, when performance was much improved. The improved performance in winter 2015 reflects numerous steps taken by market participants and PJM following the polar vortex events, and well before Capacity Performance was approved or implemented.
“So it is unclear that CP is likely to have a substantial incremental impact on future energy prices. The expected value of the incremental impact of CP on future annual energy prices is likely an order of magnitude lower than the estimated impact on capacity cost developed in this report.”
“The combination of the changes to the [variable resource requirement] curve and the CP rule changes caused capacity prices in the 2018/2019 BRA to be higher than they otherwise would have been,” PJM said in a statement. “However, PJM is confident that the implementation of Capacity Performance has been the right approach to making the grid more reliable and benefiting consumers, and that consumers will, in fact, enjoy substantial benefits in the form of lower energy prices should extreme weather conditions materialize again as they have in the recent past. The results of the annual and transitional auctions demonstrate the market was ready and prices were competitive.”
The Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities has ruled that electric distribution companies can sign contracts for natural gas capacity and pass the costs on to electric ratepayers (15-37).
Proponents of building gas infrastructure to supply electric generation have argued that the increasing reliance on natural gas requires additional pipelines to increase supply and lower high prices in the winter. After an investigation and proceeding, the DPU on Oct. 2 said the Electric Restructuring Act of 1997 did not preclude it from approving such contracts.
“The department finds that an EDC contract for pipeline capacity would be consistent with the Restructuring Act if an EDC is able to demonstrate that entering into a contract would result in cost savings for EDC ratepayers and otherwise satisfies the standard of review for approving EDC gas capacity contracts,” the order states.
The DPU’s order was in response to the state Department of Energy Resources’ April 2 petition requesting an investigation into ways new natural gas capacity could be added. The department sought to determine if there was an “innovative mechanism” for EDCs to add new natural gas capacity into the region to benefit electric ratepayers, and if cost recovery was appropriate.
“An EDC must demonstrate that the proposed contract (1) results in net benefits for the Massachusetts EDCs’ customers at a reasonable cost, and (2) compares favorably to the range of alternative options reasonably available to the EDC at the time of acquisition of the resource or contract negotiation,” the DPU order said.
Kinder Morgan subsidiary Tennessee Gas Pipeline, which is developing the proposed Northeast Energy Direct pipeline, said the order “is an important step in ensuring that electric generators have reliable access to the fuel needed to generate electricity within the ISO-NE transmission grid.” The project is among those that could be funded under the order. (See NH PUC Staff: Northeast Energy Direct Pipeline Would Lower Power Prices.)
A critic of the move, Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey, had argued during the proceeding that the restructuring law limited the regulators’ ability to act and questioned their assumptions. “Because of legal concerns with the DPU’s proposal and the risk to ratepayers, throughout this proceeding, our office urged the department to fully and carefully analyze the need for additional gas capacity before moving forward with any proposal that requires customers to bear the risk of a large infrastructure project,” said Chloe Gotsis, spokeswoman for the attorney general.
This is not the last word from Healey’s office. In July she commissioned a study to address the need for additional gas capacity in New England region. The study is expected by the end of the month.
The company producing the study, Boston-based The Analysis Group, has already looked askance at another Massachusetts energy proposal that it says saddles ratepayers with excessive costs. It recently conducted a study for the New England Power Generators Association critical of imported Canadian hydropower. (See New England Generators: State Interventions Risk Market Development.)
