MISO Consulting Advisor Terry Bilke said MISO is ready for NERC’s new frequency response reliability standard.
“We’re good right now, and we don’t see anything on the horizon that would decline our performance,” Bilke told the Reliability Subcommittee on Wednesday.
The RTO reported that 18 governor scorecards were completed and returned by utilities as of early January, and scorecards covering Sept. 1, 2015, to Dec. 31, 2015, were sent out to local balancing authorities in preparation for the rule’s April 1 effective date (BAL-003-1).
The rule requires balancing authorities to meet an annual frequency response measure (FRM) “equal to or more negative” than its frequency response obligation. The FRM is the median of frequency response performances for 20 to 35 frequency events chosen throughout the year by NERC’s Frequency Working Group.
The frequency response obligation under MISO’s field trial is ‐211 MW/0.1 Hz. MISO’s median performance from September to November was estimated at -362 MW/0.1 Hz. Those 2015 results will be submitted to NERC by March 7.
MISO said it plans to continue to “work with local balancing authorities and generators to boost governor response where appropriate.”
Bilke said if MISO was found noncompliant by NERC, MISO would have to search generator by generator until it located the source of the noncompliance. “NERC has wide latitude in what penalties they can assess,” he said in response to questions on what consequences would result from non-compliance. “We can’t predict what would happen. It would depend on how bad, how non-compliant, how receptive the parties are to making it right.”
Bilke said the fines could be as much as $1 million per day, but he said there are several options MISO can make use of before it comes to penalties. “There are ways to adjust if we see problems on the horizon.”
“I’d like frequency response to be a formal issue of the Reliability Committee. For the future, especially in light of folks concerned over the Clean Power Plan, I think this should be a formal issue,” Reliability Subcommittee Chair Tony Jankowski said.
Preparation for the rule’s deadline continues with MISO’s next governor collaboration call taking place Jan. 22.
MISO: November and December ‘Uneventful’
Senior Real Time Operations Engineer Steve Swan reviewed what he called “two relatively uneventful months” in the November and December operations updates. Swan said there weren’t any areas of concern. November’s load averaged 68.9 GW, about even with October’s load, and 6.6 GW lower than November 2014. During December, load peaked at 87.1 GW on Dec. 17, down from December 2014’s peak of 93.1 GW.
In both November and December, real-time unit commitment performance was rated “excellent” on a daily basis. Real-time unit commitment performance at peak hours was also consistently rated excellent, with the lone exception of Nov. 23, when it was given a “good” rating. December, however, achieved near-perfect ratings every day of the month.
“This is the report through December you hope to expect,” Swan said.
Neither November nor December had any capacity shortages or any periods of load so light that generators had to operate at emergency minimum levels. During the two months, there also weren’t any reliability issues. Swan said generator maintenance was on the rise in October and planned generator outages remained high during November before tapering off in December as maintenance season drew to a close.
MISO said during December, day-ahead and real-time LMPs were at their lowest levels since January 2009, when the ancillary services market was launched. The RTO credited the dip to reduced congestion.
— Amanda Durish Cook
State regulators again turned down Clean Line Energy Partners’ request to consider the necessity of its transmission line proposal without requiring it to first acquire the rights of way for the power line. Clean Line said it may not proceed with the Rock Island Clean Line project if the Utilities Board continues to require full right-of-way approval before the project’s route or need are determined.
Consumers Energy has extended a power purchase agreement with Hillman Power’s 20-MW wood-burning plant for another 17 months.
The city of Scandia, population 3,936, is embracing a $12.5 million community solar garden that private investors are building on a former 59-acre gravel pit. Scandia Mayor Randall Simonson said he wants the facility to be a showcase for other communities.
A deal to keep an underground coal mine running includes a confidential secret side agreement between the owner and an environmental group that had argued state officials failed to properly examine the long-term groundwater impacts of expanding the mine.
A new 10-MW hydroelectric power plant is being proposed for Lock C1 on the Champlain Canal in Waterford, north of Albany.
About a million customers of Duke Energy in the state have until April 13 to file a claim to be included in an $81 million class-action settlement, which resolved claims that the utility illegally paid rebates to large commercial and industrial customers at the expense of smaller customers.
The Corporation Commission has ordered the operators of 27 wastewater disposal wells to reduce wastewater injections after a swarm of earthquakes unsettled residents northwest of Oklahoma City.
State regulators have rebuffed an attempt by the Conservation Law Foundation to stall Invenergy’s application for its 1,000-MW Clear River Energy Center because of the proposed gas-fired power plant’s climate impacts.
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources is taking a two-pronged approach as it prepares to respond to EPA’s Clean Power Plan, which seeks to reduce carbon emissions from power plants.
The Eastern Interconnection Planning Collaborative has announced the appointment of Tim Ponseti as chairman of the executive committee for 2016 and Mike Kormos as vice chairman.
Consumer advocates responded positively to the Utility Regulatory Commission’s order requiring Northern Indiana Public Service Co. to resubmit its overall energy efficiency plan after deciding the utility’s filing did not include adequate goals. The commission ordered the resubmittal by 2017.
Low power prices are forcing two biomass plants to suspend operations in March, raising concerns in the state’s logging industry.
The Federal Communications Commission has reached a $540,000 settlement with Cumulus Media, the former owner of a radio station that in 2011 broadcast 178 ads supporting the Northern Pass transmission project without identifying the ad’s sponsor — Northern Pass Transmission.
PSEG Long Island will roll out a scaled-back smart meter plan aimed mostly at large commercial and solar customers after its initial plan to install 180,000 devices was shelved last year by state regulators.
Modifications to its 350-MW gas-fired power plant will reduce CO2 emissions by 4,000 tons/year, Caithness Long Island Energy says.
A coalition of state ranchers, environmentalists and disgruntled landowners has suffered a major setback in its battle to block a proposed pipeline that would carry natural gas beneath 143 miles of largely untouched Big Bend land.
TransCanada, the developer of the Keystone XL pipeline project, has sued the U.S. for failing to issue crucial permits to allow the project to proceed. The company is seeking $15 billion in damages, saying the State Department’s denial of the permit for the $8 billion pipeline was “arbitrary and unjustified.”
FERC on Friday approved Columbia Gas Transmission’s proposed $45 million Utica Access Project in West Virginia, designed to bring Appalachian shale gas to market. The project, which includes 5 miles of new pipeline and modifications to existing compression facilities, would supply up to 205 million cubic feet of gas per day to the Appalachia Pool.
FERC extended the public comment period for the Northeast Energy Direct pipeline until Jan. 15 after what it described as errors in its online comment system in late December and the first few days of January.
The Energy Department has appointed a team to research the feasibility of drilling deep holes into a crystalline rock structure in North Dakota as a possible method of storing nuclear waste. A team from the Battelle Memorial Institute will drill a test hole in the formation near Rugby, N.D., as part of the project.
