By Tom Kleckner
OKLAHOMA CITY — Reducing SPP’s current 13.6% reserve margin to 12% could cut required capacity by about 1,000 MW, saving $86 million annually and $1.3 billion over 40 years, a task force told the Markets and Operations Policy Committee.
The Capacity Margin Task Force has been evaluating resource adequacy since SPP became a central balancing authority with the Integrated Marketplace’s implementation in 2014. The RTO’s capacity margin has been unchanged since 1998 despite an expanding footprint, operational changes and significant transmission expansion.
Task Force Chairman Tom Hestermann, manager of transmission policy for Sunflower Electric Power, said the group believes the reserve margin can be reduced without affecting reliability. He said stakeholders have been supportive of reserve margins as low as 12.5% but less so when the margin drops to 12% or less.
“The more reserves you require, the more it will cost,” he told members during a four-hour educational forum preceding the MOPC meeting. “We want a good balance between reserve margins and system reliability. If 12% is where we want to be, we have a good story to tell. We believe we can do this successfully.”
The savings would come from reduced generation investment made possible by transmission upgrades. Hestermann said lower margins could align with generation retirements due to the Clean Power Plan.
Hestermann noted resource adequacy is generally expressed in terms of capacity margin or reserve margin for planning purposes. Both are measured using the same numerator: the difference between available resources and net internal demand. SPP uses capacity margin, in which resources serve as the denominator. Reserve margin, used by NERC and other regions, uses net internal demand as the denominator.
Hestermann said the task force will recommend switching to reserve margin, where a 13.6% margin is equivalent to a 12% capacity margin.
“NERC doesn’t have a standard for planning reserves,” Hestermann said. “SPP enforces this requirement through the membership agreement.”
The task force ran “limbo studies” — “How low can you go?” Hestermann explained — that simulated four reserve margin levels for each of three years: 2016, 2017 and 2020. The analysis found SPP could maintain required loss-of-load expectations in every case except 2017, and then only when the reserve margin was set at 7.53%. (The study assumed additional transmission infrastructure.)
“The current criteria requires an assessment every two years to ensure 12% is adequate,” Hestermann said. “What we haven’t done before is see whether we can go lower than that and still maintain a reasonable level of reliability.”
The task force has completed a white paper defining load-responsible entities, which was approved by MOPC and the board last July and is currently being discussed within various task forces. Tariff revisions or changes to previously approved policy will be brought back to the MOPC for approval.
The group will present its reserve margin requirements and a deliverability study for MOPC approval in April. It also will present a planning reserve assurance policy, an enforcement mechanism using payments, not penalties, from LREs short on capacity to those who are long.
The task force also is still working on a distributed energy resource policy.
Thomas Klink has been named CFO of Pioneer Power Solutions, a Fort Lee, N.J., manufacturer of electric transmission, distribution and generation equipment. He takes the place of Andrew Minkow, who left to pursue other opportunities.
Dominion Virginia Power says it will spend $9.5 billion in capital improvements through 2020, including $700 million in solar facilities. The company said it will spend $2.4 billion on its distribution system, $3.6 billion on transmission lines and substations and $3.5 billion on new generation.
Exelon Nuclear announced it has completed its multiyear uprate of Peach Bottom Atomic Power Station Unit 3, which boosts the capacity of the Pennsylvania reactor to 1,355 MW from 1,180 MW.
Battery maker Axion Power International has filed an interconnection application with PJM for a site in Sharon, Pa., where it seeks to develop a 12.5-MW energy storage system.
FERC has given Exelon Generation’s Muddy Run Pumped Storage Facility on the banks of the Susquehanna River a 40-year license extension after the company promised a number of improvements to the site for recreation and to permit passage for American shad and American eels.
Westar Energy has reached an agreement with an affiliate of NextEra Energy Resources to purchase another 200 MW of Kansas wind energy.
Apex Clean Energy is expecting to develop Tennessee’s largest wind farm, to be located in Cumberland County.
David B. Hamilton has been named site vice president at FirstEnergy’s Perry Nuclear Power Plant in Perry, Ohio, replacing Ernie Harkness, who is retiring. Frank Payne will move into Hamilton’s previous position of general plant manager.
State regulators again turned down Clean Line Energy Partners’ request to consider the necessity of its transmission line proposal without requiring it to first acquire the rights of way for the power line. Clean Line said it may not proceed with the Rock Island Clean Line project if the Utilities Board continues to require full right-of-way approval before the project’s route or need are determined.
Consumers Energy has extended a power purchase agreement with Hillman Power’s 20-MW wood-burning plant for another 17 months.
The city of Scandia, population 3,936, is embracing a $12.5 million community solar garden that private investors are building on a former 59-acre gravel pit. Scandia Mayor Randall Simonson said he wants the facility to be a showcase for other communities.
A deal to keep an underground coal mine running includes a confidential secret side agreement between the owner and an environmental group that had argued state officials failed to properly examine the long-term groundwater impacts of expanding the mine.
A new 10-MW hydroelectric power plant is being proposed for Lock C1 on the Champlain Canal in Waterford, north of Albany.
About a million customers of Duke Energy in the state have until April 13 to file a claim to be included in an $81 million class-action settlement, which resolved claims that the utility illegally paid rebates to large commercial and industrial customers at the expense of smaller customers.
The Corporation Commission has ordered the operators of 27 wastewater disposal wells to reduce wastewater injections after a swarm of earthquakes unsettled residents northwest of Oklahoma City.
State regulators have rebuffed an attempt by the Conservation Law Foundation to stall Invenergy’s application for its 1,000-MW Clear River Energy Center because of the proposed gas-fired power plant’s climate impacts.
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources is taking a two-pronged approach as it prepares to respond to EPA’s Clean Power Plan, which seeks to reduce carbon emissions from power plants.
The Eastern Interconnection Planning Collaborative has announced the appointment of Tim Ponseti as chairman of the executive committee for 2016 and Mike Kormos as vice chairman.
Consumer advocates responded positively to the Utility Regulatory Commission’s order requiring Northern Indiana Public Service Co. to resubmit its overall energy efficiency plan after deciding the utility’s filing did not include adequate goals. The commission ordered the resubmittal by 2017.
Low power prices are forcing two biomass plants to suspend operations in March, raising concerns in the state’s logging industry.
The Federal Communications Commission has reached a $540,000 settlement with Cumulus Media, the former owner of a radio station that in 2011 broadcast 178 ads supporting the Northern Pass transmission project without identifying the ad’s sponsor — Northern Pass Transmission.
PSEG Long Island will roll out a scaled-back smart meter plan aimed mostly at large commercial and solar customers after its initial plan to install 180,000 devices was shelved last year by state regulators.
Modifications to its 350-MW gas-fired power plant will reduce CO2 emissions by 4,000 tons/year, Caithness Long Island Energy says.
A coalition of state ranchers, environmentalists and disgruntled landowners has suffered a major setback in its battle to block a proposed pipeline that would carry natural gas beneath 143 miles of largely untouched Big Bend land.
TransCanada, the developer of the Keystone XL pipeline project, has sued the U.S. for failing to issue crucial permits to allow the project to proceed. The company is seeking $15 billion in damages, saying the State Department’s denial of the permit for the $8 billion pipeline was “arbitrary and unjustified.”
FERC on Friday approved Columbia Gas Transmission’s proposed $45 million Utica Access Project in West Virginia, designed to bring Appalachian shale gas to market. The project, which includes 5 miles of new pipeline and modifications to existing compression facilities, would supply up to 205 million cubic feet of gas per day to the Appalachia Pool.
FERC extended the public comment period for the Northeast Energy Direct pipeline until Jan. 15 after what it described as errors in its online comment system in late December and the first few days of January.
The Energy Department has appointed a team to research the feasibility of drilling deep holes into a crystalline rock structure in North Dakota as a possible method of storing nuclear waste. A team from the Battelle Memorial Institute will drill a test hole in the formation near Rugby, N.D., as part of the project.