By Tom Kleckner
The Public Utility Commission of Texas said it will invite stakeholder comments as it takes a cautious approach to Lubbock Power & Light’s planned integration into the ERCOT grid.
“I think this is an incredibly complicated situation. I’m not sure it’s even clear how … we evaluate it,” PUC Chair Donna Nelson said during the commission’s June 29 open meeting. “I do have concerns about the FERC jurisdiction aspect of it … I’m concerned about [Lubbock] having generation that flows outside of Texas.”
“We need to be mindful of the precedent it sets,” Commissioner Ken Anderson agreed. “I believe there might be other entities in Texas — other regions, groups — that look with envy on ERCOT, and for good reason.”
LP&L announced last September it planned to disconnect from SPP and join ERCOT by 2019. Xcel Energy, whose Southwestern Public Service subsidiary serves LP&L’s load, asked FERC in May for an $88.7 million interconnection switching fee should the municipal utility proceed with its plan. (See Xcel Asks for $88.7M Fee for Lubbock Switch to ERCOT.)
Nelson, Anderson and Commissioner Brandy Marty Marquez all said they would like to see LP&L’s integration turned into two separate cases, one involving the move from SPP’s grid to ERCOT’s, and the other involving a cost-benefit analysis of the transfer on ratepayers. Nelson said she would issue a memo outlining the parameters on further studies before the PUC’s next open meeting July 20 (Docket No. 45633).
An ERCOT study completed in June indicated it would cost $364 million and take 141 miles of new 345-kV right of way to incorporate LP&L into ERCOT. (See “LP&L Integration Could Unlock More Panhandle Wind Energy,” ERCOT Board of Directors Briefs.)
The City of Lubbock has told the PUC it would prepare an impact analysis of the LP&L load that would migrate to ERCOT, using the Texas grid operator’s report as a starting point. It said its report will be “holistically framed around three key areas of study”: the effects on existing ERCOT stakeholders, on existing SPP stakeholders and on Lubbock customers.
“I think it’s appropriate to allow people to file responses to the ERCOT filing and to what Lubbock has filed,” Nelson said. “We have to make sure ERCOT [and] the ratepayers of Texas are treated fairly. I think SPP and the ratepayers in SPP should be treated fairly too.”
Marquez said one of her concerns is “what happens to the communities that are left behind, and what kind of rates do they absorb?”
Anderson said he wants more “clarity” from ERCOT on the available integration options, saying the ISO’s preferred option “seems to be predicated on the assumption that most of what they are recommending will be needed anyway.”
“If two years later we have to go back and approve what ERCOT recommended,” Anderson said, “by then, we may have way overpaid.”
The municipality has said it faces time constraints in meeting its 2019 timeline, but the commissioners said that wasn’t their primary concern.
“I’m not going to take on that responsibility,” Nelson said. “We need to avoid putting ourselves in a position where we’re there to rescue the day if people have put themselves in that position.”
“These are Texans, but these are Texans that didn’t want us,” Marquez said. The SPS region opted out of Texas’ competitive market before it opened in 2002.
Municipal utilities Austin Energy and CPS Energy of San Antonio, both ERCOT members, also opted out of competition.
Great Plains Energy and Westar Energy filed a joint application with the Kansas Corporation Commission to approve the $12.2 billion sale of Westar to Great Plains.
The Eau Clair Energy Cooperative has hit upon an energy-saving, green method of controlling the vegetation at its solar farm in Fall Creek: sheep.
Alliant Energy has put Wisconsin’s largest solar installation, built on top of a coal-ash landfill, into service.
Pipeline giant Energy Transfer Equity has called off its proposed acquisition of Williams Co., following a Delaware judge’s ruling that the transaction could be terminated. The deal was valued around $38 billion, including debt, when it was reached in September.
GridLiance and the Kansas Power Pool announced a collaboration to improve the transmission infrastructure in KPP’s service area.
San Diego Gas and Electric is the first California investor-owned utility to meet its cap under the state’s original net energy metering (NEM) rule, which restricts projects eligible for net metering to 5% of a utility’s peak load.
The newly expanded Panama Canal locks will be able to handle 90% of the world’s LNG tankers, reducing shipping time and expense for shipments to Asia from Gulf Coast terminals, according to the Energy Information Administration.
The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, rejecting a Sierra Club challenge, has ruled that an Enbridge oil pipeline that crosses a national forest in Michigan doesn’t need a new permit to keep operating.
